If it comes with two penises and no justification, not so great.
I just had a horrible image of the world's worst polyjuice potion story. *scrubs brain*

I want motivation, not just porn.

Even when I try to write PWP, I get motivation. Case in point, Nice Girl.

but said author refused to read it because it wasn't slash.

Now I just don't get that some time. I, for one, love all well-written and in character fics. I'm also the grammar fiend, which comes from being a freaking reporter, I guess.

*blink*

I'll raise your blink and give you a Huh?

:P